Five Outrageous Ways Your Roofer Is Overcharging You

Janice Seril • May 15, 2023

Find out the top sneaky tactics that scheming roofers use to overcharge unassuming homeowners.

We've all seen it in the news: lots of people from all over the country are getting conned by roofers, with many of these crooks posing as tradies from legit roofing companies. I'm sure you don't want to fall victim and lose your hard-earned cash to scammers.


Today, we're gonna take a look at the five outrageous ways that roofers may overcharge their clients. Now, when I say outrageous, I mean tactics are sneaky, slimy, and downright dodgy. But don't worry, by the end of this article, you'll know exactly what to look out for and how to avoid falling victim to these scams.

Overcharging Tactic #1: Upselling Unnecessary Services

Let's kick off with the first outrageous way that your roofer might be overcharging you: upselling unnecessary services. Now, don't get me wrong, there are certain situations where additional services may be required to properly fix your roof. However, some roofers may try to convince you that you need additional services that aren't actually necessary. They may even use scare tactics to make you think that your roof is in worse shape than it really is. This is a classic case of trying to squeeze more money out of you for services that you don't really need.


Here's an example: Let's say you call up a roofer to repair a leak in your roof. They come out to inspect the damage and tell you that in addition to fixing the leak, you also need to have your entire roof replaced. They tell you that the damage is much worse than it appears and that your roof is on its last legs. They might even say something like "If you don't replace your roof now, you're looking at a total roof failure within the next few months."


Now, while it's certainly possible that your roof may need to be replaced, it's also possible that the roofer is trying to upsell you on services that aren't actually necessary. In this scenario, it's important to get a second opinion from another roofer to confirm the diagnosis. It's also a good idea to ask the roofer for more information about why they think the entire roof needs to be replaced. If they can't provide a solid explanation, it's probably a sign that they're trying to overcharge you.

So, how do you avoid falling for this upselling tactic? It's important to do your research before hiring a roofer. Check their reviews online and ask for references from previous clients. You want to make sure that you're working with a reputable and trustworthy roofer.


When you're getting a quote for roof repairs, make sure to ask for a detailed breakdown of the services that are required. If the roofer suggests additional services, ask for an explanation of why they're necessary. If you're not satisfied with their answer, get a second opinion from another roofer.


Most importantly, don't be afraid to negotiate on the price. If you feel like the roofer is trying to upsell you on unnecessary services, speak up and let them know that you're not interested in those services. A good roofer will be honest with you about what services are necessary and won't pressure you into paying for additional services that you don't need.

Overcharging Tactic #2: Hidden Fees and Charges

Another way that roofers may overcharge their clients is by hiding fees and charges in the fine print. They may give you a quote for a certain amount but then tack on additional fees and charges once the work is completed. This can be incredibly frustrating for homeowners who are trying to budget for their roof repairs. It's also a dishonest tactic that can erode trust between the roofer and the client.


This one really hits me because I have personally experienced this. I once hired a roofer to repair some damaged metal sheets on our roof. They gave me a quote for $1,500, which I agreed to. Once the work is completed, however, they presented me with a bill for $2,000. 


What the hell?!

When I asked about the additional charges, they told me that they had to make some unexpected repairs and that there were additional fees for materials and labour. I was left mortified and felt taken advantage of. Worse, I had no choice but to pay for it.


Don't fall victim to this sneaky as-hell tactic by making sure to get a detailed quote from the roofer before they begin work. This should include a breakdown of all the services that are required, as well as the costs associated with each service. Make sure to ask if there are any additional fees or charges that you should be aware of.


It's also a good idea to ask the roofer for a written contract that outlines the scope of the work, the timeline for completion, and the total cost of the project. This will help to ensure that there are no surprises when it comes time to pay the bill.


Finally, make sure to read any contracts or agreements carefully before signing them. Look out for any hidden fees or charges that may be buried in the fine print. If you're not sure about something, ask the roofer for clarification before signing.


I failed to do all three and it cost me a lot. Learn from my experience and don’t be a victim.

Overcharging Tactic #3: Inflated Material Costs

Aah. This one is a real classic among dishonest contractors. Some roofers who are looking to make a quick profit overcharge their clients by inflating the costs of the materials they use, By charging more for materials than they actually cost, they can increase their profit margin and take advantage of unsuspecting homeowners.


Imagine that you hire a roofer to replace some damaged metal sheets on your roof. They tell you that the cost of the materials will be $500, which seems reasonable. However, when you receive the bill at the end of the project, you see that you've been charged $800 for the materials. When you question the roofer about this, they tell you that the cost of the materials has gone up since they gave you the initial quote. If you're not aware of how much the materials actually cost in the market, you will surely fall victim to this kind of ruse.


To avoid falling victim to inflated material costs, try to get multiple quotes from different contractors to compare prices. You can also do some research online to get an idea of what the average cost of the materials should be.


To avoid falling victim to inflated material costs, try to get multiple quotes from different contractors to compare prices. You can also do some research online to get an idea of what the average cost of the materials should be.


When you're getting a quote from a roofer, ask them to break down the costs of the materials so that you can see exactly what you're paying for. If you notice that the costs seem unusually high, ask the roofer to explain why. A trustworthy roofer will be happy to provide you with this information.


It's also a good idea to ask the roofer if they have any partnerships or discounts with suppliers. This can help to ensure that you're getting the best possible price for the materials.

Overcharging Tactic #4: Overestimating the Scope of Work

Did you know that roofers can also overcharge their clients by overestimating the scope of work? This tactic involves exaggerating the amount of work that needs to be done in order to justify charging a higher price. It's a sneaky and downright dirty way for dishonest contractors to make more money from unsuspecting homeowners.


Let's say you need to have a part of your roof repaired. Just that. When you hire a roofer to do the job, they tell you that the entire roof needs to be replaced, even though only a small part of your roof needs to be repaired. They claim that there is extensive damage that you can't see and that it's in your best interest to replace the entire roof. This is an example of overestimating the scope of work.


Again, the best way to avoid falling into this scheme is to get multiple quotes from different contractors. This will give you a better idea of what the actual scope of work is and what a fair price for the job should be.

You can also ask for a detailed breakdown of the work that needs to be done so that you can understand exactly what you're paying for.


It's also a good idea to educate yourself on common roof repair issues and their solutions. This will help you to better understand what needs to be done and what doesn't. If a roofer is claiming that extensive work needs to be done, but you know that it's not necessary, it's a red flag that they may be overestimating the scope of work.


When you're getting a quote from a roofer, make sure to ask them to explain why they believe the entire roof needs to be replaced. A trustworthy roofer will be able to provide you with a detailed explanation of the work that needs to be done and why it's necessary. If the roofer is unable to do this or seems antsy, it's a sign that they may not be trustworthy.

Overcharging Tactic #5: Using Low-Quality Materials to Cut Costs

Some roofers may try to cut costs by using low-quality materials during the repair process. While this may make the initial cost of the repair cheaper, it can lead to more expensive repairs in the future. This tactic is especially prevalent in the roofing industry, where some unscrupulous contractors will use subpar materials to maximize their profits.


Imagine you've hired a roofer to replace some metal sheets on your roof. The roofer offers to use cheaper, low-quality sheets to save you money. You agree, thinking that you're getting a good deal. However, within a few years, those metal sheets start to rust and develop gaping holes, leaving your roof vulnerable to leaks and other damage. This can end up costing you more money in the long run, as you'll have to pay for another repair or even a full replacement.


We cannot stress this enough: hire a reputable local roofing contractor. Look for roofers who use high-quality materials and have a track record of satisfied customers. You can also ask the roofer to provide you with a detailed breakdown of the materials they will be using, including the brand and quality level.


When you're getting a quote from a roofer, be wary of any price that seems too good to be true. A significantly lower price may be a sign that the roofer is cutting corners by using low-quality materials. It's always better to pay a little more upfront for high-quality materials that will last longer and require fewer repairs in the future.

There you have it. Arm yourself with the knowledge and hire a reliable team of roofers to avoid these five appalling ways of being overcharged by your roofer. Not only you will save money but you will also spare yourself the heartache and frustration that only scam victims feel after they've been ripped off and left with a shoddy roof.


Looking for a reputable roofer in Mackay? Look no further than
Mackay Roofing. Get a free estimate by calling us at 07 4277 7726. Our staff is always available to answer your queries.

By Janice Seril 15 May, 2023
Is your roofer charging you a fair price or do you feel like you're being ripped off? Find out whether roofer rates here in Mackay are justified or not.
By Janice Seril 14 May, 2023
When it comes to gutter replacement, is it a good idea to go the DIY route or hire a pro to do the job for you?
06 May, 2023
Not all roofs are created equal, from the materials used to the design. But how can you know that your roof is built to last?
Share by: